The ford Mustang has “American” written all over it. Few domestic cars are more entitled to this car’s iconic status. From Steve McQueen to Carroll Shelby, the The Mustang has more than earned its leading role in car lore.
Back in the day, the release of this consummate American car tapped into an unrealized pool of desire for high-performing cars that didn’t break the bank. In 1964, Mustang sales went through the roof.
Today, the Mustang meets that same demand. Buyers want to get their hands on the wheel of a rugged performance machine. They want to hear the satisfying growl of exhaust fumes coming out of the manifold, they want to feel the rumble of idling and they want to experience a full gallop on the open road. But at the end of the day, Mustang drivers know they still have money left over for fuel.
American muscle isn’t for all performance car enthusiasts. This was not the case a year after the debut of the Mustang. Then it appeared in the timeless James Bond movie Golden Finger (1965) and in Bullitt (1968). In the latter, it’s still thrilling to watch Steve McQueen rampage through San Francisco like a taunt chasing the bad guy in that legendary green Mustang. Now let’s look at affordable American muscle in the used car market. These are the cheapest used Ford Mustangs to buy in 2023.
10 Ford Mustang from 2010
The 2010 Ford Mustang has the power and attitude we expect from this iconic emblem. The rumble of a 2010 Mustang is music to any gearhead’s ears, especially in the 4.6-liter V8 premium version. The classic appeal of this Ford sports cars has an aggressive hood style, which comes standard in both the V6 and V8. A 2010 Ford Mustang coupe can be had for a bargain in the $10,000-$15,000 range, if you don’t mind having over 100,000 miles.
9 Ford Mustang from 2009
There’s plenty to like about the 2009 Ford Mustang. At the top of the list is its looks. The 2009 styling stays true to the timeless lines of the original ’60s Ford Mustang. And, best of all, it is relatively affordable. One downside is the gas mileage, which only adds up to 19 miles per gallon. But frankly, abysmal fuel economy isn’t something Mustang enthusiasts will look at.
8 Ford Mustang from 2014
The 2014 Ford Mustang marks the end of the line for the fifth-generation Mustang. That’s good news for buyers, as the price of the 2014 Ford sports car is dropping. And these fifth-generation used sports cars feature upgrades for driver comfort, such as heated seats.
7 Ford Mustang from 2011
The 2011 Ford Mustang is one of Ford’s most reliable Mustangs for its handling and overall performance. It created excitement in 2011 when newer engines were introduced in both the V6 and V8.
However, you may want to avoid a 2011 model with GT trim. Higher than average reports of engine and transmission problems are well documented with the NHTSA. And in the 2014 Mustang GT with manual transmission, a slipping gearbox reportedly disrupted gear changes.
6 Ford Mustang from 2007
As a fifth-generation Ford Mustang, the 2007 model offers comforts such as six-way electronic front and passenger seat adjustment and heated seats. Retro looks make this used sports car attractive. And the retro style translates to the dashboard in the interior with a double hood design.
Overall it’s a comfortable everyday driver, a good find for an old Ford sports car.
5 Ford Mustang from 2008
The 2008 Ford Mustang is one of the better model years. This iteration is powerful in its 4.0-liter V6 configuration and performs well in the 4.6-liter V8, making the 2008 Ford Mustang a great buy for its performance value. It is the first fifth generation with side airbags.
The retro style is another reason why the 2008 Mustang delights buyers. The model has a retro vibe, but these bangs will never look old.
4 Ford Mustang from 2017
As part of the sixth-generation iteration, the 2017 Ford Mustang introduced new engine construction and offered an infotainment system for the first time. It’s good to know that the 2017 Mustang wasn’t available in the new 3.7-liter V6 at dealerships, but initially it was.
There was excitement around the new 5.0-liter and 5.2-liter V8 Coyote engines, but complaints have been filed with the NHTSA about the electrical system and other matters. Buyer beware.
3 Ford Mustang from 2012
Driving the 2012 Ford Mustang gives you that inimitable experience only found behind the wheel of one of these timeless American classics. The 2012 model delivers the experience better than some. It is the second year that the V6 had the larger engine. To put it in perspective, the boost to 305 horsepower was more powerful than the former Mustang V8s. It also has a larger boot space, a sports car bonus.
All in all, the 2012 Ford Mustang boasts impressive performance, big torque, strong power and great value.
2 2019 Ford Mustang
The 2019 Ford Mustang has received critical acclaim from critics. JD power proclaimed it an “owner’s dream” for reliability and American news reported a 9.3 out of 10 critics, with a performance of 8.9 out of 10. Not too shabby.
While the 2019 iteration is great across the board, one feature that makes it a used car goldmine is the EcoBoost option. The EcoBoost engine delivers 310 horsepower to your hands, which is fantastic for a used sports car.
1 Ford Mustang from 2013
This 2013 Ford Mustang model has a special advantage within its model year. A Mustang Boss 302, a powerful pony that pays homage to the classic Mustang originally produced in 1969 with the same name. The 2013 Boss has a V8 engine with power up to 444 horsepower. A Shelby V8 is also available, as in every model year.
But even the 2013 Mustang’s V6 option is powerful. This model is also known for its solid handling and responsive acceleration. In short, the 2013 pony is great value for a used sports car.